A few days ago I entered a competition on the MediaDevil Facebook page to win one of their new Grafikcases featuring the design of my choice (as long as it wasn’t copyrighted – which threw the Bat Symbol right out the window).  As some of my blog readers will know, I’m a computer graphic design dabbler so this is exactly the sort of prize that gets my juices flowing.  So this is a very cool prize from a very cool UK-based company who make, in my humble opinion, the best screen protectors out there.  I used to show Zagg’s InvisibleShield a lot of love until I started using MediaDevil products a year ago when I got the Magic Screen Protector Matte Clear Anti-Glare edition for my 1st Generation iPad (also available for the iPad 2) and I haven’t looked back.  I also now own both the front and back versions of the MediaDevil (PhoneDevil) Magic Screen Protector Crystal Clear edition for iPhone 4 / 4S.  They’re thin and work perfectly with every case I’ve tried the with.  But I digress.  Back to the Grafikcase.

First draft of a Grafikcase using my current and alternative gamer tags.

I debated using the GingerNinja or GeekDad3 logos I’ve created for this blog and as gamer tags or even a collage of the two showing a kind of transition (as I may migrate from GingerNinja to GeekDad3 as discussed previously); but then I realised that I should probably use a design featuring what I spend most of my free time working on or thinking about: karate.

I discussed things with Sean over at MediaDevil and he sent me a Photoshop template to use in place of the PNG file I originally submitted and I sent over a simple Essex Dragon logo with my name and region details underneath to make the case unique and personal.  It was after this that the product page for the case came back online after it had been down and I noticed that the image transferred onto the case could actually wrap around the sides of the case.  Cue more discussions with Sean and an updated version of my design, which is based on my Facebook Cover Photo, with some kanji in the background and the GKR initials logo at the top in the whitespace next to the camera lens.

I got an email late Friday night from Sean saying that they’d kindly made both of the designs that I’d sent over, one with a matte finish and one with a glossy finish, and put them in the post as my prize.  I was amazed at their generosity and more than a little excited!  They arrived on Saturday morning so I thought I’d post some pictures and review them.  I should point out that I have sample products as they are still working out the kinks and that the final commercially available products may differ to the ones I have on review here.

Packaging & first impressions

Left: Glossy Grafikcase. Right: Matte Grafikcase.

Despite the temporary nature proclaimed on the label, I actually really like the packaging.  It’s minimal and if the stickers said something like “bespoke Grafikcase created by MediaDevil especially for [insert name here]” then this would make the packaging make more sense to people as it already does to me:  the product has been made for me and is unique.  It doesn’t need big, heavy blister retail packaging as it’s not designed to be around the case for very long.

Construction & Fit

In terms of construction and fit, both cases are superbly snug in a great way and won’t just pop off; they grip the phone and feel very secure.  Additionally, both cases are more than happy with the fact that I kept my MediaDevil iPhone 4/4S Back Protector on my iPhone which means that should any dust or grit get between case and phone (as often happens) then the glass on the iPhone back will not suffer for it as has happened with cases & phones past.  Some iPhone cases also hate you having a screen protector on the front, let alone one on the back too but the Grafikcases show no sign of concern when paired with the Crystal Clear screen protectors.  Perhaps this is by design, coming from the same manufacturer?  The case is also very low profile adding only about 2mm to the profile of the iPhone.  Finally, the buttons are all accessible on both the iPhone 4 and 4S so no problems there.

Matte case

This is the first revision of my design and I’m rather pleased with it, even if I did miss the second hyphen in “Go-Kan-Ryu” which I’ll correct with a Sharpie!  I didn’t intend for the badge to wrap around onto the left hand side of the case so I can only assume that some minor tweaking was required during printing.

Certainly something seems to have happened during manufacture or printing as the top of the case in the middle, where the power button and headphone jack are, is slightly melted as if the thermal printing damaged the case in some way.  I don’t particularly mind though as my finger actually sits very comfortably in the groove when using the phone, the quality isn’t promised to be spot on as it’s a pre-release sample and it was free.  (A particular bugbear of mine recently has been people moaning about the free stuff on 12 Days of iTunes.  It’s free.  Stop looking a gift horse in the mouth, people!)

The matte finish gives a slightly duller finish to the image, obviously, so the colours are less vibrant but you also get zero reflection so you can see the image in all lighting conditions.  It also feels absolutely lovely to hold with an almost micro-suede feel to the back of it.  Think plastic MacBooks from 2006-8, MacBook Pro/Air cases today, brushed aluminium or a smooth pebble on the beach that hasn’t been polished by anything other than nature.  Smooth but not glossy,  lovely to hold and very tactile indeed: you want to stroke it.

As previously mentioned, the fit of the case itself is snug and secure.  It fits, in the words of Jim Carrey in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, ”like a glove”.  For me this case is now a better fit than the Apple bumper, which had started to become loose, making this case my new daily case of choice.

Glossy case

In terms of first impressions, the 2nd revision design case has the wow factor for me as it just looks more vibrant and I love the kanji wrapping around the case and the fact that I spelt the club name properly on this one *cough, cough*.   The only design change I would possible make on this one would be to move the GKR initials logo downwards to ensure it sits nicely next to the camera opening so that the lines are clean on the image, or possibly removing it altogether as I find it jarring to see it floating out of alignment with the opening.

Whilst I like the fact that the glossy finish ensures that all the colours really stand out, this also makes the case reflective and so you sometimes cannot see the image clearly under bright sunshine.  Also, the glossy powder coating, whilst making you think the phone will feel smooth & slippery, is actually slightly more grippy to hold as the smooth surface has an increased area for resistance.  Despite feeling like polished granite to the touch, it feels plasticky when I go to remove it from my pocket, so I find it less tactile.  Another downside of what I presume is the extra coating required to make it glossy is that it makes the fit even snugger almost to the point of being difficult to put on and take off the device with the back protector on.

Conclusion

Whilst the glossy case wins in terms of looks, of the two, for me personally the matte case wins in terms of how nice it feels in the hand.  After all, I’m going to spend more time holding it than I am looking at the back of it, so the feel is what wins it for me.

You can find out more about the MediaDevil Grafikcase here.  Comments can be made or questions can be asked below.

(I’m still slightly torn between the two different image designs.  I reckon I probably prefer the 2nd revision, so that on a matte case if probably the “perfect” choice.  Still need to look at that top-right logo though.  Hmmm.)